It felt like a seminal moment in the 24-year-old American’s career; a culmination of hard work and raw talent which has long been heralded as the potential future of men’s tennis in the country.
Now, with Tiafoe reaching the semifinals by beating Andrey Rublev in straight sets Wednesday 7-6 7-6 6-4, he has recorded the best grand slam result of his career – the achievement made all the more impressive given his humble beginnings.
The crowd at Arthur Ashe Stadium delighted in the play of Tiafoe, the first Black American man to reach a US Open semifinal since Ashe in 1972. And in a match where he didn’t lose a service game to the world No. 11, he couldn’t let them down.
“I feel so at home at courts like this. This court is unbelievable. You guys get so far behind me, you know I want to play and want to give it my best. I always find a way somehow on this court. I always try to play great tennis and I have been,” he said in an on-court interview just after the match.
“Let’s enjoy this one. We got two more guys. We got two more.”
Tiafoe’s route into tennis has been in no ways traditional.
His parents met in the US after leaving Sierra Leone and had twins together, Franklin and Frances.
Their father, Constant Tiafoe, started working at the Junior Tennis Champions Center in Washington, D.C. back in 1999 and eventually moved into one of its vacant storage rooms while working around the clock.
His two boys would sometimes stay with him, sleeping on a massage table, while their mother worked night shifts as a nurse.
The unusual gateway into the sport gave Tiafoe an opportunity to start developing his skills and, after beginning to train at the facility, he didn’t look back.
“Obviously, I wasn’t the wealthy kid or wasn’t having all the new stuff or whatever. But I was just living life. I could play tennis for free, the sport I loved,” he told CNN Sport back in 2015, adding that he wouldn’t change his upbringing for the world.
He was asked Wednesday what message people should draw from his story.
“I mean, anybody can do it, honestly. Obviously that’s a cliché, but I think if you are really passionate about something… Everybody’s got a gift,” he said, adding that his passion and obsession is tennis.
Driven by the work ethic of his parents, he won the prestigious Orange Bowl – one of tennis’ most prized junior tournaments – at 15, becoming the youngest boys’ singles champion in the tournament’s history.
He joined a list of previous champions which included Roger Federer, Andy Roddick, Ivan Lendl, Jim Courier, John McEnroe and Bjorn Borg.
It was a sign of things to come.
Tiafoe turned professional in 2015 and started getting familiar with the rigors of the senior tour.
He broke into the world’s top 100 and began to assert himself at grand slams – reaching his first quarterfinal at the Australian Open in 2019 before losing to Nadal.
Three years on and he found himself Wednesday at another quarterfinal as the world No. 26, only this time he felt more ready to grasp the opportunity.
“Honestly, when I first came on the scene, I wasn’t ready for it mentally and mature enough,” he said on court after beating Nadal. “I’ve been able to develop and I have a great team around me.
“I’m happy I won in front of my mom, my dad, my girlfriend and my team and to have them see what I did.”
While he cements himself as a contender on the court, Tiafoe is also pursuing social justice off it.
In 2022, he told CNN Sport that the lack of diversity in the sport had made him feel like an “outsider,” and he vowed to continue fighting for equality while he still had the platform to do so.
He created a protest video in 2022 to raise awareness of racial injustices after the death of George Floyd sparked protests across the world.
In collaboration with a host of Black players and coaches – such as Serena Williams and Coco Gauff – he posted the “Racquets down, hands up” video to his social media channels.
“Are we going to help everyone? Of course not, but I’m definitely going to help as many people as I can. That’s my duty,” he told CNN Sport at the time.
On Wednesday, his coach, Wayne Ferreira, said Tiafoe’s story is movie material but he needs to win the US Open or another grand slam event first.
“You only get movies if you do well,” he said. “But his story is very unique, and it’s a great story. And he’s very humbled. He’s a very, very, very nice individual. Very great heart and kind. You’ve got to love him. He’s truly special.”
Make no mistake, though, this is no overnight success story. It’s a product of thousands of hours of work and a mentality that won’t take no for an answer.
However, while the weight of a nation rests on his shoulders, Tiafoe has always just focused on making his parents proud.
“With them trying so hard, I felt like I didn’t want to let them down,” he told CNN Sport in 2015. “I felt like I didn’t want to let the opportunities go for granted.”
Tiafoe will now play Carlos Alcaraz for a place in the final after the Spaniard fought through a marathon match against Jannik Sinner, with the encounter finishing just before 3 a.m. local time.
With Alcaraz expending so much energy, it presents a golden opportunity for the American to continue his run and he will certainly have the support of the home crowd.
“That stuff gets me emotional, for sure. Seeing people screaming your name, just loving what you’re doing. That’s awesome. That’s what it’s all about,” Tiafoe told reporters after the match.
“You know, everyone loves a Cinderella story. [I’m] just trying to make one.”